Combined recipe for clinical target volume and planning target volume margins.

Abstract

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A widely accepted PTV margin recipe is M(geo) = aΣ(geo) + bσ(geo), with Σ(geo) and σ(geo) standard deviations (SDs) representing systematic and random geometric uncertainties, respectively. On the basis of histopathology data of breast and lung tumors, we suggest describing the distribution of microscopic islets around the gross tumor volume (GTV) by a half-Gaussian with SD Σ(micro), yielding as possible CTV margin recipe: M(micro) = ƒ(N(i)) × Σ(micro), with N(i) the average number of microscopic islets per patient. To determine ƒ(N(i)), a computer model was developed that simulated radiation therapy of a spherical GTV with isotropic distribution of microscopic disease in a large group of virtual patients. The minimal margin that yielded D(min) <95% in maximally 10% of patients was calculated for various Σ(micro) and N(i). Because Σ(micro) is independent of Σ(geo), we propose they should be added quadratically, yielding for a combined GTV-to-PTV margin recipe: M(GTV-PTV) = √{[aΣ(geo)](2) + [ƒ(N(i))Σ(micro)](2)} + bσ(geo). This was validated by the computer model through numerous simultaneous simulations of microscopic and geometric uncertainties.

PURPOSE

To develop a combined recipe for clinical target volume (CTV) and planning target volume (PTV) margins.

RESULTS

The margin factor ƒ(N(i)) in a relevant range of Σ(micro) and N(i) can be given by: ƒ(N(i)) = 1.4 + 0.8log(N(i)). Filling in the other factors found in our simulations (a = 2.1 and b = 0.8) yields for the combined recipe: M(GTV-PTV) = √({2.1Σ(geo)}(2) + {[1.4 + 0.8log(N(i))] × Σ(micro)}(2)) + 0.8σ(geo). The average margin difference between the simultaneous simulations and the above recipe was 0.2 ± 0.8 mm (1 SD). Calculating M(geo) and M(micro) separately and adding them linearly overestimated PTVs by on average 5 mm. Margin recipes based on tumor control probability (TCP) instead of D(min) criteria yielded similar results.

CONCLUSIONS

A general recipe for GTV-to-PTV margins is proposed, which shows that CTV and PTV margins should be added in quadrature instead of linearly.